LEADERSHIP & CULTURE

How to Talk to an Employee Who Is Struggling: A Manager’s Guide to the Check-In Conversation

Quick answer

Name what you have noticed, ask an open question, and then listen without fixing. Do not diagnose, do not promise what you cannot deliver, and do not make the conversation about performance unless that is genuinely why you asked. If the person mentions not coping or not wanting to be here, ask directly and escalate to the appropriate person. Then follow up within days, because the check-in is the start of support, not the end of it.

On this page
  1. The shift that makes it possible
  2. How to open
  3. What to do with what comes back
  4. What not to say
  5. Then follow up
  6. What to do this quarter
  7. Where CALM fits
  8. Key takeaways
  9. References

Why managers wait

Three fears stop the check-in: saying the wrong thing, opening something you cannot close, and bringing a private matter into work. Underneath, they are one fear: that once you ask, you need to fix whatever the problem is. You do not. Not having the conversation teaches the person that nobody noticed.

One in five Australian adults experience a mental disorder in any year, and many more go through distress without a diagnosis: separation, a sick parent, grief. You need not know which it is to ask.

Audrey on the manager who waits. Why managers delay the check-in (fear of saying the wrong thing, fear of opening something they cannot close, fear of the HR process), what that delay costs, and the one shift that makes the conversation possible: you are not there to fix it.

The shift that makes it possible

You are not there to fix it. Your job is to connect, ask, listen and monitor. Letting go of the need to solve changes how you behave: you talk less and stop steering towards the answer that would make you feel better. Being heard without being managed is often the first relief people feel.

How to open

Pick a private time with no clock pressure. A walk can feel safer than a closed door.

Name two or three specific changes you have noticed, not what you think they mean. For example, ‘You have been quieter lately and the last two reports were late, which is not like you’. Avoid long lists as it starts to read like a case being built. Then ask an open question. How are things going for you at the moment?

Then stop. The silence that follows is not yours to fill.

What to do with what comes back

If they say they are fine. You can accept it once. Few open up on the first ask, especially to their manager. But you can also stay silent but present. Often silence will encourage the person to open up. If you don’t get them to open up, leave the door open and check in again later. The second ask often gets you the truthful answer. 

If they open up. Listen. Do not diagnose, compare it to your own experience or rush to the EAP number. Reflect back what you hear so they know you listened.

Then ask what would help at work right now. It may be small: a deadline moved, a different shift, fewer meetings for a fortnight. Those adjustments are yours to offer. Sometimes the answer is nothing; they needed someone to know.

If they get upset. Stay regulated. Slow your breath and your pace. Tears are not an emergency. Often they mean the person feels safe enough to stop holding it together. Give them time and a choice: keep going or take a break?

If they say something that worries you, such as not coping or not sure why they bother, ask directly about their safety, including thoughts of suicide. Asking does not increase risk. If the answer is yes, stay with them and connect them to help now. Do not leave them alone.

What not to say

Do not tell them to be more resilient or that everything will be ok or that it’s not that bad. 

Do not get distracted or try to fix it too soon. 

Do not promise confidentiality you cannot keep; say who you would involve and why. If you are concerned for their safety do not just give them a number to call, stay with them until someone equipped to support takes over from you. 

Then follow up

The check-in is the first move. Note what was agreed. Check in again within days, then keep checking. If you offered an adjustment, make sure it happened and ask whether it helps. This is the Monitor step in the CALM method, and the one managers most often skip. Then debrief with someone you trust: holding distress costs you too.

What to do this quarter

  1. Give every people leader a simple conversation structure and the chance to practise it with realistic scenarios.
  2. Make sure managers know the escalation path, including what to do in the moment, not just who to email.
  3. Set an expectation that managers follow up, and ask about it in leadership check-ins.
  4. Clarify what confidentiality managers can and cannot offer, so they do not promise the wrong thing.

Where CALM fits

CALM Conversations trains managers to hold this conversation with confidence. Managing Strong Emotions gives leaders a framework for the reactions they fear most. Suicide Prevention in the Workplace is for anyone who may hear the words that stop the room. Both are practical and built for people who are not mental health professionals.

If you or someone you know needs support, contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or Beyond Blue on 1300 22 4636. In an emergency, call 000.

Key takeaways

  • Around one in five Australians aged 16 to 85 experienced a mental disorder in the previous 12 months. Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics, National Study of Mental Health and Wellbeing 2020-2022
  • Low support from managers is a named psychosocial hazard. Source: Safe Work Australia, Model Code of Practice
  • Serious mental health claims grew 161% over the ten years to 2023-24. Source: Safe Work Australia
  • Asking someone directly about suicide does not increase risk. Source: Dazzi et al. (2014), Psychological Medicine

Frequently asked questions

How do I start a conversation with an employee I think is struggling?

Choose a private moment, name two or three specific changes without judgement, and ask an open question. Then listen, and expect they may not open up the first time. You are there to notice and connect, not to diagnose or fix.

Can a manager ask an employee about their mental health?

Yes, with care. A manager can ask how someone is going and whether work is affecting them. A manager should not diagnose, pressure someone to disclose a condition, or link the conversation to a performance warning. Reasonable adjustments can be offered without a diagnosis.

What should I do if an employee says they are not coping?

Stay with the conversation and ask what would help at work right now. If anything they say concerns you, ask directly about their safety, including thoughts of suicide. Connect them to support in the moment, agree next steps, and follow up within days.

References

  • Australian Bureau of Statistics, National Study of Mental Health and Wellbeing 2020-2022
  • Safe Work Australia, Model Code of Practice: Managing psychosocial hazards at work
  • Safe Work Australia, Key Work Health and Safety Statistics Australia 2025
  • Dazzi, T. et al. (2014), Does asking about suicide and related behaviours induce suicidal ideation? Psychological Medicine (web team: add DOI)
  • Fair Work Ombudsman, Managing performance and mental health

AB

Audrey Bevan

Clinical Lead, CALM Conversations

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vestibulum tempor pellentesque ipsum, non mollis neque interdum eget. Nam in ex a ante tincidunt laoreet et id lorem. Fusce a varius risus. Aliquam elementum ultrices auctor. Morbi nec mauris ac risus venenatis cursus. Nulla sollicitudin accumsan mi, id rutrum turpis tempus quis. Sed mollis nunc ut ligula sodales, vel tincidunt

Calm conversations can save lives.

Give your people the practical skills to respond to distress with confidence, compassion and clarity.